This “Pretty Little Liars” Theory May Have Just Solved The “Who Is Charles?” Mystery

This "Pretty Little Liars" Theory May Have Just Solved The "Who Is Charles?" Mystery
Has this "Pretty Little Liars" theory solved the Charles mystery once and for all?! Watch the video here and decide for yourself!

Pretty Little Liars fans are nothing if not semi-professional sleuths. You have to be inquisitive and eager in order to keep up with this show and its never-ending stream of coincidental deaths, creepy texts, and mysterious masks.

At the end of season 5, we learned that Charles – whose origin and true identity is still unknown – is the big bad ‘A’ that has been terrorizing and blackmailing the Liars. Well, now the mystery will revolve around “Who is Charles?” Marlene King, the show’s creator, has promised that this will be the #SummerOfAnswers and will delve deeply into Charles’ origin story.

But, in the meantime, it’s still fun to speculate with fan theories.

This one theory, from one fan at Bustle, is so incredibly detailed that I, the constant skeptic, am having a hard time not believing it. Watch the video below to find out exactly who she believes Charles to be:

What do you think of this theory that dearly-departed Garrett is actually Charles? If someone came out with that theory with no concrete proof to back it up, I’d be just as wary to believe them as a Rosewood police officer. But, these clues are hard to deny. What do you think?

Pretty Little Liars season 6 premieres tonight at 8PM EST on ABC Family! Join our Twitter chat tonight for the chance to win season 5 on DVD!

What do you think of the “Garrett is Charles” theory?

Are you following on Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, Instagram, Google+, and Tumblr? Make sure to sign-up for our mailing list to get daily entertainment updates right to your inbox!

– Read our comment policy! –


(1283 Posts)

Jordan is the founder of He is also a writer, graphic designer, and pop culture freak of nature. When he's not tweeting about chocolate, he can be found working in public relations and social media. He lives in Toronto, Canada.