It ended with a Bukayo Saka cross straight into the arms of Nick Pope. A floated, telegraphed supply despatched extra in hope than expectation, which summed up an Arsenal efficiency missing creativeness and perception.

The clock learn 96 minutes as Newcastle defended their field and the Gallowgate Finish demanded to listen to the ultimate whistle. It had the look and theatrics of a title challenger barging down the door within the seek for an equaliser, however it didn’t have that really feel.

The largest concern for Arsenal is not only that the 1-0 defeat leaves them fourth (and probably as little as sixth by Sunday night), seven factors behind Liverpool after 10 video games. It’s that Arsenal have returned to the risk-averse method that made a lot of the primary half of final season so stale.

The nearer Arsenal have gotten to Manchester Metropolis, the extra Mikel Arteta has sought to squeeze the margin for error. Eradicating the bandwidth for spontaneity, condensing the sport into fewer huge moments and decreasing huge video games to low-xG affairs has turn into the recipe for visits to locations like St James’ Park.

The meanest defence and probably the most suffocating press was the bedrock of final season’s title problem. It was largely efficient, albeit a grind quite than glamorous, however Arsenal moved away from that at first of the calendar yr, rising from a poor run over Christmas as a staff unburdened. The improved freedom noticed them rating 31 targets in seven video games and so they have been rampant for an prolonged interval.

The primary 10 video games of this season, whether or not accidentally or design, has seen a gradual return to a extra attritional method. With solidity prioritised, it has seen Arsenal evolve right into a practical staff in possession that not often surprises, in comparison with the expansive model that initially turned them into title challengers in 2022-23.

The issue with a restrictive method is that if you happen to go behind it’s troublesome to loosen the reins, significantly in case your midfield has been composed to compete quite than management. Arsenal have discovered this out the exhausting means, having fallen 1-0 behind in 4 of their final six Premier League video games, as many as their earlier 31.

Saturday’s loss — the primary time they’ve misplaced consecutive video games at St James’ since a run of three between 1994 and 1996 — was a repeat of the failure a yr in the past. Solely this time, there was no controversy over Newcastle’s purpose to distract from Arsenal’s deficiencies.

Final November’s defeat was the second-lowest xG of any Arsenal sport final season and the one time in 38 video games that they’d fewer than two photographs on course in a sport. They repeated that undesirable feat on Saturday with solely a single shot testing Pope.

In Martin Odegaard’s absence, the midfield has turn into an unproductive zone. Mikel Merino regarded caught between three positions, as did Leandro Trossard. No participant was connecting the totally different sections of the staff.

It was the seventh sport from 10 that Arsenal didn’t create over 1.0 anticipated targets (xG) from open play. A big a part of their open-play complete of 0.65 xG at Newcastle got here from Declan Rice’s headed miss within the 93rd minute, the one second within the sport that Arsenal created a clear-cut likelihood outdoors of dead-ball conditions.

And that’s the concern for Arsenal. The one time Newcastle and the house crowd appeared to sense imminent hazard was when Arsenal had a nook or a free kick.

Creating so many goalscoring alternatives from set items could be a superpower. It has been for Arsenal on many events, significantly in breaking the impasse or getting them degree, however there’s a hazard that it begins to compensate for a scarcity of likelihood creation.

Arsenal have solely registered 37 photographs (7.4 per sport) on the highway this season, the second-lowest complete behind Brentford. They’ve had a really robust schedule thus far having travelled to Aston Villa, Manchester Metropolis, Tottenham, Bournemouth and Newcastle however these numbers nonetheless paint an image of their attacking ambitions.

The absence of Odegaard, whose return from ankle ligament injury is imminent, was initially overcome by Arteta displaying flexibility in his alternative of form however he has turn into conspicuous by his absence.

It’s troublesome to flee the conclusion that Arsenal’s sport is over-reliant on the Norwegian, with 17-year-old Ethan Nwaneri the one comparable kind of participant within the squad.

“Yeah, we don’t have him. We are able to focus on that every one day lengthy,” stated Arteta after Saturday’s sport.

“We haven’t had him for the final 4 or six weeks and we don’t have him but. However we’ve many different solutions which have been very efficient. In the present day we have to have a look at ourselves and congratulate Newcastle and transfer on.”

They have been struggling to create possibilities within the early months of final season, too, however the essential distinction is that they have been capable of fall again on the watertight defence.

Whereas Newcastle have been commonly successful duels and lower by way of Arsenal’s midfield 4 or 5 instances within the first half, which could have been an unsettling sight for Arteta.

“You understand the sport they need to play. It’s clear,” stated Arteta of Newcastle.

“You get dragged into that type of sport too typically and we weren’t ok and didn’t have sufficient solutions to get out of that continually, particularly to create the menace that we wanted and mentioned.”

Is it a case of Arsenal being so distracted by the concept of successful the battle that their technical means suffers because of this? Arsenal regarded in determined want of a participant taking cost and bringing some route to their play.

“It’s simpler to say it than to get it executed,” stated Arteta. “We knew and we respect that each opponent has its traits and qualities. They’re excellent at what they do.”

Arteta tried to achieve management. He launched Oleksandr Zinchenko as an inverted full-back, moved Thomas Partey from right-back into midfield and gave Ethan Nwaneri greater than half an hour. He even threw on Jorginho within the 86th minute in a bid to seek out some rhythm however it by no means got here.

Arsenal at the moment are winless of their final three Premier League video games. The two-0 loss to Bournemouth had the caveat of William Saliba’s purple card and the 2-2 draw with Liverpool was towards a title rival.

It’s too early for panic however, no matter context, Arsenal discover themselves in a rut. Two seasons in the past they may not untangle themselves from a defensive decline that set in in the course of the run-in, whereas final season it was a run of 5 video games in December that proved expensive.

Arsenal are too sturdy and constant a staff to fade away however they have to be bolder and revive the spark of their attacking play if they’re to forestall this unhealthy run from turning into terminal.

(Header photograph: George Wooden/Getty Pictures)