Ryan Murphy isn’t publicly calling for Erik Menéndez and Lyle Menéndez to be launched from jail after receiving backlash for the way his present Monsters portrays their notorious homicide case.

“I wouldn’t go as far as to say they need to be freed, however I believe that their case needs to be reexamined, and I believe new proof needs to be offered,” Murphy, 58, instructed Folks on Friday, September 27. “If that case was tried and the entire proof was allowed in right now, I believe they most likely would’ve been charged and located responsible of manslaughter and they might be out of jail now.”

Murphy is hopeful that Monsters “finally results in one thing constructive” for Erik, 53, and Lyle, 56.

“Did they go too far? Sure. Have been they out of their minds on the time? Sure. However they’ve been mannequin prisoners,” he famous. “I’ve talked to folks within the jail who declare they’re completely rehabilitated and might truly do good for society in some capability now, and I believe that deserves to be checked out.”

The manager producer went on to clarify why his tackle the case was “so controversial,” including, “Folks aren’t comfy with the concept that two issues will be attainable on the similar time. They need good guys and dangerous guys. They don’t need difficult guys.”

Murphy particularly pointed to Erik and Lyle’s previous authorized points. Erik and Lyle turned prime suspects within the murders of their mother and father — José and Kitty Menéndez — in 1989. They had been subsequently arrested in 1990 earlier than being discovered responsible of first-degree homicide and sentenced to life with out parole in 1996 after two high-profile trials.

“I believe Eric and Lyle did monstrous issues — not simply the murders, however the different crimes they dedicated. I believe they had been morally corrupt at a younger age. When you consider the testimony and in the event you consider the proof, I believe the mother and father had been additionally monsters,” he continued. “However the household says I’m a monster as a result of I dared to debate it, and that’s OK. I don’t thoughts being difficult. I do know that my intentions had been good. We simply actually wished folks to speak about this subject and it’s an uncomfortable subject, which I get.”

In Netflix’s Monsters, which was launched earlier this month, Nicholas Alexander Chavez portrayed Lyle and Cooper Koch performed Erik. José and Kitty, in the meantime, had been portrayed by Javier Bardem and Chloë Sevigny, respectively.

The actual-life Erik spoke out towards the present in the future after it was launched after viewers took subject with scenes alluding to an incestuous relationship between the siblings.

“I believed we had moved past the lies and ruinous character portrayals of Lyle, making a caricature of Lyle rooted in horrible and blatant likes rampant within the present,” learn Erik’s assertion, which was shared by way of Lyle’s Fb web page. “I can solely consider they had been executed so on objective. It’s with a heavy coronary heart that I say, I consider Ryan Murphy can’t be this naive and inaccurate concerning the information of our lives in order to do that with out dangerous intent.”

Murphy, for his half, stood by how the present selected to cowl the homicide case — together with the rumors that had been unfold on the time of the trial.

“I really feel like that’s fake outrage,” Murphy instructed Folks. “As a result of in the event you take a look at what we do, we give these boys a lot airtime to speak about what they declare as their bodily abuse. We reside in a type of tradition of shock that lots of issues are knee-jerk, and that’s fantastic. I’m used to being controversial. It’s not new to me.”

It was essential for Murphy that Monsters not decide a aspect.

“I don’t know what story they might wish to be instructed. How do you assassinate the character of two individuals who killed their very own mother and father? I discover that an attention-grabbing alternative of phrases, and I don’t agree with it. Additionally, I believe perhaps they don’t even assume it’s true,” he continued. “And 65 p.c of the present is devoted to [Erik and Lyle’s] perspective that, ‘We had been sexually abused and that’s why we did what we did.’ We are saying that again and again and over, so I don’t perceive what the household can declare didn’t occur as a result of we’re presenting every part that occurred as an opinion of different folks.”

Murphy went on to level out that the Monsters crew wasn’t “doing a documentary” on the Menéndez brothers. (Netflix introduced an upcoming documentary titled The Menéndez Brothers, which can characteristic new interviews with Erik and Lyle, days after Monsters was launched.)

“I used to be involved in doing one thing about all people concerned on this case, together with the mother and father and their views,” Murphy defined. “We’re not presenting any [of the incest speculation] as reality. We’re presenting it as somebody’s opinion. All of that stuff is woven right into a narrative that [Vanity Fair author] Dominick Dunne talked about in articles. It was additionally thrown up in courtroom a number of instances. I’m not saying that it occurred. I’m not saying that it didn’t occur. I’m saying that it was part of the large folkloric tapestry of that case which may have swayed juries in a sure method or not.”

Monsters is presently streaming on Netflix.