For extra on the 2024 race, head to the NPR Community’s elections updates web page.

Late Tuesday afternoon, the Harris marketing campaign launched a video of Tim Walz speaking about gun management. Walz, whom Kamala Harris lately introduced as her operating mate, talks about banning assault rifles as a part of what he calls “frequent sense” proposals.

“We will ensure that these weapons of battle, that I carried in battle, is the one place the place these weapons are at,” Walz mentioned within the video.

That was all Republican vice presidential nominee JD Vance wanted.

“Effectively, I ponder, Tim Walz, when have been you ever in battle? When was this?” Vance mentioned.

The vice presidential candidate is meant to be an assault canine, generally touchdown the decrease blows which may appear unpresidential. However Vance and Walz are additionally each veterans, with one other factor in frequent: neither one in every of them noticed fight. Their service shored up every ticket, including a army credential beside two presidential candidates that by no means served. It didn’t look like a problem. However on this compressed marketing campaign season, Walz’s phrasing opened up a line of assault — and the Trump marketing campaign took it, accusing the Minnesota governor of one of the vital grievous fees doable in army circles.

Conflict, fight and repair – and a cost of “stolen valor”

Walz joined the Nationwide Guard at age 17 and served 24 years, first in Nebraska then Minnesota. Throughout that point he obtained referred to as as much as nationwide disasters and a deployment to the Arctic Circle in Norway. He accomplished his 20 years required for retirement in 2001, however then reenlisted after the assaults on Sept. 11. His solely wartime deployment was to Italy in 2003, backfilling troops that have been deploying to Afghanistan. So Vance, and lots of veterans on social media, took concern with Walz saying he’d carried weapons “in battle.”

The Harris marketing campaign mentioned in an announcement: “In his 24 years of service, the Governor carried, fired and educated others to make use of weapons of battle innumerable occasions. Governor Walz would by no means insult or undermine any American’s service to this nation — actually, he thanks Senator Vance for placing his life on the road for our nation. It is the American means.”

However Vance went lots additional, with an assault that the Trump marketing campaign in all probability had ready.

“What was this weapon that you just carried into battle, given that you just deserted your unit proper earlier than they went to Iraq, and he has not spent a day in a fight zone? What bothers me about Tim Walz is the stolen valor rubbish,” Vance mentioned.

Since Walz first ran for Congress after which governor, he’s confronted assaults across the timing of his retirement. Vance’s accusation echoes one made by two fellow high-ranking sergeants from the Minnesota Guard who publicly attacked Walz in 2018, in a paid endorsement letter to the editor of the West Central Tribune. They slammed Walz for “conveniently retiring a yr earlier than his battalion was deployed to Iraq.”

In keeping with the Minnesota Nationwide Guard, Walz retired in Could 2005, two months earlier than his unit, the first Battalion, a hundred and twenty fifth Discipline Artillery acquired an alert order for mobilization to Iraq in July 2005. It’s seemingly that Walz put in for retirement months earlier than that Could. It’s additionally clear that guardsmen anticipated deployment to Iraq months earlier than July.

In keeping with a number of of his contemporaries within the guard Walz talked about it as a tough resolution: that if he deployed he’d miss his finest likelihood to run for Congress.

“He weighed that call to run for Congress very, very heavy,” Allan Bonnifield, who served with Walz, informed Minnesota Public Radio in 2018. “He cherished the army, he cherished the Guard, he cherished the troopers that he labored with, and making that call was very powerful for him. Particularly realizing that we have been happening one other deployment to Iraq. He didn’t take that call frivolously in any respect.”

The unit didn’t go to Iraq till March 2006, 10 months after Walz retired, the place it stayed for a grueling 22-month prolonged deployment. The cost has dogged Walz, and in his final run for governor in 2022, it was even leveled by a political opponent who by no means served in any respect.

Walz’s rank

The newest spherical of assaults on Walz stirred up one other complicated level about his rank. Walz served as a command sergeant main, the best enlisted rank. However his retirement papers put him one step decrease – a grasp sergeant. The Minnesota Nationwide Guard informed NPR that Walz retired earlier than finishing educational necessities to maintain the upper rank.

“He held a number of positions inside subject artillery corresponding to firing battery chief, operations sergeant, first sergeant and culminated his profession serving because the command sergeant main for the battalion. He retired as a grasp sergeant in 2005 for profit functions as a result of he didn’t full extra coursework on the U.S. Military Sergeants Main Academy,” mentioned Military Lt. Col. Kristen Augé, the Minnesota Nationwide Guard’s state public affairs officer.

So whereas Walz can say he served as a command sergeant main, which additionally made him the best enlisted member serving in Congress, and he may even get away with saying he retired as a command sergeant main, he can’t say he’s a “retired command sergeant main.” On Thursday the Harris marketing campaign modified Walz’s official bio on their web site to replicate that.

Prices of “swiftboating”

Attacking an opponent’s army service has a brief historical past in presidential campaigns – the verb “swiftboat” dates again solely 20 years, when George W. Bush’s marketing campaign attacked combat-decorated John Kerry’s army service in Vietnam, which could have appeared dangerous since Bush prevented serving there. Donald Trump, who additionally prevented going to Vietnam, took the tactic to a different stage, attacking his GOP critic John McCain’s storied standing as a POW. Now, Harris supporters are claiming that Vance is making an attempt to “swiftboat” Walz, and even pointing to a member of the Bush-era marketing campaign who’s now working for Trump.

Veterans teams are typically holding out of the fray; many veterans service organizations are on report praising the selection of two enlisted army veterans as vice-presidential nominees.

“Which means that whatever the end result in November, the subsequent vice chairman of the USA can be a former enlisted service member. I’m happy to see each main events acknowledge that army service is as soon as once more a valued expertise in selecting the candidate for the second highest place within the nation,” Veterans of Overseas Wars Nationwide Commander Al Lipphardt mentioned in an announcement.