Jac Schaeffer Talks Episode 4 Reveal and Mephisto

[This story contains spoilers through Agatha All Along’s fourth episode, “If I Can’t Reach You / Let My Song Teach You”]

After creating Marvel Studios’ most profitable collection in WandaVision, Agatha All Alongside showrunner Jac Schaeffer rewarded herself with the director’s chair. Along with being Disney+’s most watched new collection of 2021, Schaeffer’s present garnered 23 Emmy nominations, three wins and, for good measure, a chart-topping single known as “Agatha All Alongside.” So, when the time got here to do a derivative with Kathryn Hahn’s Agatha Harkness within the title function, Schaeffer knew she needed to reignite her directorial ambitions, which had been final on show in 2009’s Timer.  (The sci-fi rom-com was led by WandaVision and Agatha All Alongside actor Emma Caulfield.)

“Once you’re fortunate sufficient to have a undertaking be successful [WandaVision] and also you then have some capital, the query turns into: how are you going to spend your capital? And one of many solutions to that query was parlaying it right into a return to directing,”  Schaeffer tells The Hollywood Reporter of directing a number of episodes this season. “There’s nothing prefer it. Writing one thing and being the one to execute it after which moreover seeing it by put up, it’s the last word.”

Agatha All Alongside neared its midway level with author Giovanna Sarquis and director Rachel Goldberg’s fourth episode, “If I Can’t Attain You / Let My Track Educate You.” Its ending — following the coven’s newest trial on Witches’ Street — revolves round an intimate second between Agatha and Aubrey Plaza’s Rio, as Agatha tries to rekindle their presumably tragic romance from years previous. Nonetheless, as an alternative of returning Agatha’s try at a kiss, Rio drops the revelation that Joe Locke’s mysterious character, Teen, isn’t Agatha’s deceased son, Nicholas Scratch, in some new form or type. 

As for whether or not the viewers ought to consider the crafty Rio, Schaeffer can solely say a lot right now.

“I simply assume it’s in regards to the dynamic between Agatha and Rio. At this level within the story, it’s unimaginable for them to seek out one another, and that’s the actual query,” Schaeffer says. “Clearly, they’ve a lot chemistry they usually have a lot warmth, so what’s the issue? That’s actually what that scene factors to.”

In author Cameron Squires and Goldberg’s third episode, “Via Many Miles of Tips and Trials,” Sasheer Zamata’s Jennifer Kale raises the topic of Scratch to Teen, positing the rumor that he is likely to be an “agent of Mephisto.” The latter is a demonic Marvel supervillain whose potential presence on WandaVision was closely theorized about in ways in which overwhelmed Schaeffer on the time. The large unhealthy by no means truly appeared, however following the WandaVision finale, Schaeffer insisted that she nonetheless didn’t have a lot of an curiosity in him or the opposite persistent scuttlebutt involving Magneto.

However now that Mephisto has really entered into her work, Schaeffer candidly admits that the choice outranks her. 

“It was a dialog with [Agatha] government producer Mary Livanos, [Marvel’s head of streaming] Brad [Winderbaum] and [Marvel Studios boss] Kevin [Feige], however it’s a point out that’s bigger than me and this present. It’s the bigger Marvel-ness of it,” Schaeffer shares. “So it isn’t about me bristling or having any form of a response or agenda, largely as a result of that sort of fevered discourse that may be very, very rooted within the comics is just not as fascinating to me as the present story being informed within the collection at hand.”

Under, throughout a current spoiler dialog with THR, Schaeffer additionally addresses the idiosyncratic nature of Patti LuPone’s fan-favorite Lilia, earlier than confirming a WandaVision-related principle concerning Debra Jo Rupp’s Sharon Davis.

We spoke beforehand about the way you had been again in Kate Winslet territory with the Agnes of Westview fantasy in Agatha All Alongside’s collection premiere, and shortly after that, I talked to Craig Zobel, who directed Mare of Easttown in its entirety. The dialog was largely about how he needed to reference Matt Reeves’ The Batman on his new collection, The Penguin, however then I broke the information to him that Agatha All Alongside had simply referenced his work on Mare. So he lit up as a result of he was unaware of it, and he was genuinely touched to be a reference for the primary time. You made his day.

Thanks for sharing that and for transmitting that message. I’m pleasant with [Mare showrunner] Brad Ingelsby, and he and I’ve emailed a bunch about [Agatha]. His response has been so beautiful and gratifying and a reduction. You by no means understand how individuals are going to take it, however he appears to be delighted by it, in order that interplay has been nice. I don’t know Craig, however I’ve heard by colleagues how fantastic he’s. In fact, I understand how proficient he’s, so thanks for telling me that. That’s simply actually nice to listen to. 

I do know you pitched the thought of the status drama as a form of 180 from basic sitcoms, however did a part of you select Mare as a result of Mare and Agatha each had deceased sons that weighed closely on them?

Yeah, that was undoubtedly a part of it. Kate is so extraordinary on that present, and Kathryn is able to that degree of excellence in her work. We additionally checked out The Killing and True Detective, however Mare, of current tasks, is such a pinnacle. It turned our true north within the characterization of Agnes of Westview, for positive. Folks can’t escape Mare. There are exhibits that hit after which fade, however individuals nonetheless speak about Mare, and it appears to me that it’ll stay a basic.

Gosh, I haven’t thought of The Killing in a very long time. I’ll always remember the finally controversial tagline of, “Who killed Rosie Larsen?”  

Yeah, and naturally, there was Twin Peaks. We had a author in our room who’s so into Twin Peaks that it filtered in. However I’m so delighted that the joke that Agnes of Westview relies on a Danish collection has gotten a bit little bit of traction. That joke is straight from The Killing. [Writer’s Note: AMC’s The Killing  was based on the Danish series Forbrydelsen.] And once I was writing the pilot, I consider that the very humorous Will Arnett parody detective present [Murderville] was airing on Netflix, and that was such an overt send-up of the [genre’s] tropes that it simply felt prefer it was in all places on the time. It was very zeitgeist-y.

Have you ever forgiven me for asking whether or not Evan Peters’ Ralph B. was ever within the combine to play Evan’s personal Mare of Easttown character? (Schaeffer beforehand quipped, “Now I want I might reshoot the pilot.”)

There’s nothing to forgive. I relish any alternative to consider Evan Peters, who’s so fantastic.

You directed three episodes on Agatha All Alongside together with the collection premiere with the Agnes of Westview fantasy. Was getting again within the chair a prerequisite in case you had been going to guide one other Marvel collection? 

Yeah, it actually was. Directing is what I at all times needed to do, however I discovered extra alternatives as a author than I did as a director. So while you’re fortunate sufficient to have a undertaking be successful [WandaVision] and also you then have some capital, the query turns into: how are you going to spend your capital? And one of many solutions to that query was parlaying it right into a return to directing. It’s so satisfying. There’s nothing prefer it. Writing one thing and being the one to execute it after which moreover seeing it by put up, it’s the last word.

I consider it had been 15 years because you final directed, so did you seek the advice of director associates and use them as a sounding board when you acquired again into the swing of issues?

Yeah, it had been a very long time, and I might say that the folks that I actually leaned on had been my rapid colleagues on [Agatha All Along]. So I actually leaned on my director of images, Caleb Heymann, and I employed him as a result of he was so snug with the truth that I didn’t have any episodic directing expertise. I additionally had two ADs who had been equally simply very chill about the truth that I wasn’t as skilled at directing on this scale. You need the AD division to have your again, and so all of that was actually nice. 

However then I reached out to colleagues, and a few of these conversations had been technical: “What number of setups do you get in a day?” Generally, I used to be wanting on the schedule and being like, “Am I loopy that that looks like an excessive amount of?” So I might possibly bounce it off a good friend they usually’d be like, “Yeah, that’s an excessive amount of. You want to ask for one more day or determine a approach to decrease.” Nevertheless it was primarily like, “Am I going to be okay?” And the reply was at all times like, “Yeah, directing is having an opinion and you’ve got loads,” so that you’ll be okay.

We additionally talked about how a lot the overabundance of fan theories affected you on WandaVision and the way you took some preventive measures this time round in order that an unnamed aerospace engineer didn’t flip into Reed Richards once more. Thus, was Joe Locke’s Teen designed to be an invite for fan theories? Was he your manner of telling individuals to let free? 

I wouldn’t say that was the first goal of the design. For each WandaVision principle that felt a bit bit prefer it went off the rails, there have been 20 theories that had been pleasant each in them being appropriate or being issues that the writers and I wanted we had considered. So the delight and the ingenuity far outweighs the queasy feeling of, “Oh man, that’s gone within the mistaken route.” So, greater than the thriller of Teen being a response to the wackadoo theories, I might say that the development of the mysteries was an try and squeeze much more juice out of that enjoyable. It additionally has a utility within the present, which I can’t totally converse to since you’ve acquired to see the entire present to totally embrace it, however it isn’t a thriller for thriller’s sake.

Teen was additionally on the receiving finish of Jenn Kale’s “agent of Mephisto” line, and I discovered that fascinating since you as soon as informed me that you simply weren’t actually inquisitive about him throughout our WandaVision finale speak. That mentioned, given all of the Mephisto theories, I get why you’d really feel that manner at that particular second in time. Anyway, since some writers actively bristle in opposition to fan service, did you want some convincing to lastly go there in some capability?

I wouldn’t say that I wanted convincing. It was a dialog with government producer Mary Livanos, [Marvel’s head of streaming] Brad [Winderbaum] and [Marvel Studios boss] Kevin [Feige], however it’s a point out that’s bigger than me and this present. It’s the bigger Marvel-ness of it. So it isn’t about me bristling or having any form of a response or agenda, largely as a result of that sort of fevered discourse that may be very, very rooted within the comics is just not as fascinating to me as the present story being informed within the collection at hand.

There’s been all kinds of theories that Teen is both Wanda or Agatha’s son, and in episode 4, Rio appears to remove the latter chance concerning Agatha being the mom. Can we take her at her phrase? Ought to we?

Effectively, first she says, “That boy isn’t yours.” Let’s see, how do I reply this? That is the place issues get sweaty proper in the course of the present. I simply assume it’s in regards to the dynamic between Agatha and Rio. At this level within the story, it’s unimaginable for them to seek out one another, and that’s the actual query. Clearly, they’ve a lot chemistry they usually have a lot warmth, so what’s the issue? That’s actually what that scene factors to.

Yeah, it’s been implied that Agatha and Rio, or Agathio, had a doomed romance prior to now. 

(Laughs.) I simply learn “Agathio” this morning! I used to be like, “Oh my goodness, wow!”

I didn’t understand that that portmanteau was a factor but. Anyway, Rio dropped the reveal about Teen within the midst of Agatha attempting to kiss her. Why did Rio resolve to break that tender second between them and damage Agatha much more?

Once more, it’s onerous to essentially speak about this as a result of there’s a lot but to unfold, however I respect the query very, very a lot, and I want to attempt to reply it as greatest I can. I might simply say that Rio’s curiosity in Agatha has a number of depth to it. Once we first see them collectively as their true selves in that struggle on the finish of 101, it’s all enjoyable and video games. It’s hair pulling and scratching and knives and sexiness, however there’s actual ache and actual craving.

Was Aubrey Plaza doing double obligation based mostly on her absence between one and 4?

Effectively, it’s not often only a sensible factor. Within the writers’ room, we knew that Rio can be so particular, and we had been attempting to titrate how flamable we needed their interactions to be. So we knew we couldn’t have them collectively on a regular basis as a result of it’s not a rom-com. It’s not about two individuals with cute battle who then fall into mattress with one another. So we at all times knew that Rio wouldn’t be round all the time, and I consider the development of the episodes predated Aubrey’s availability. However, sure, we didn’t have her totally in the best way that will’ve made issues simpler. Nonetheless, I might say these selections had been extra about story. 

There’s a number of “justice for Sharon,” however there’s additionally a number of “the place’s Rio?” And a part of our job is holding again. You possibly can’t give all people every thing they need on a regular basis. You want a bit ache and a bit frustration in your watch to maintain you going.

In episode three, when Agatha lastly drinks the wine, Sharon (Debra Jo Rupp) instantly says, “Please, please. Wanda, I’m begging you. Let him breathe.” Is that what she was attempting to say in WandaVision’s collection premiere as her husband (Fred Melamed) choked at dinner? Was Wanda’s spell stopping her from saying these particular phrases? 

I’ve by no means truly considered it in such stark phrases, however I might say sure. That’s her unconscious speaking in revisiting that horrific second, yeah.

Alongside the identical traces, what morsel of perception are you able to present concerning Lilia’s (Patti LuPone) outbursts?

I can’t truly converse to it an excessive amount of as a result of Lilia is a personality whose characterization and arc unfurls extra slowly than the remainder. However she’s a kook. We all know that to date.

When you acquired most of them again, had been there any Westview townspeople from WandaVision that you simply needed to deliver again however couldn’t for no matter purpose? 

It will’ve been enjoyable to discover a approach to deliver again the oldsters within the commercials. They had been terrific, however that was its personal bizarre area that was separate from the present itself. So, in my Twilight Zone thoughts, I couldn’t make it make sense to tug these individuals out of the commercials and put them into the city. However I used to be delighted that we had the Westview firm again, they usually’re all fantastic. They had been all collectively on the premiere in L.A., and it was like one large group hug. They’re only a actually particular firm.

WandaVision had a number of interplay with MCU films. It revisited Avengers: Age of Ultron and Captain America: Civil Conflict, and it needed to lead into Physician Unusual within the Multiverse of Insanity, in addition to The Marvels. Was there much less of that on this collection? Have been you capable of silo yourselves from the films? 

There was much less of that on this present as a result of Agatha hasn’t appeared in any of the options. We didn’t have the burden of retrofitting any canon. On WandaVision, each Paul and Lizzie [Elizabeth Olsen] had a lot backstory in themselves and between one another. So their moments of romance within the movies are so petite, however they meant a lot to these two performers. So we needed to underscore these moments and fill them out extra. We additionally had the bigger Scarlet Witch burden of the Infinity Stone and that form of factor. Even with WandaVision, it was much less about the way it suits with future properties. We had a few of that, nevertheless it was extra, “How can we nestle this in what already exists and each improve the story we’re telling and buttress the tales which have come earlier than?” It’s heartbreaking to disavow or tear down what’s already been established, and [upholding the past stories] was a part of our work there. So we didn’t have that work in as large of a manner on Agatha All Alongside as a result of Agatha is her personal fowl.

Interconnectivity is cool, however typically it’s good to only take pleasure in a present by itself phrases.

To be trustworthy, I didn’t truly understand how useful interconnectivity is. Most writers have an infinite creativeness, and when one thing could be something, that may be daunting. So while you’re like, “It could possibly solely be this factor, however do it nicely,” I discover that form of liberating. Once we had been first wanting on the Witches’ Street and the way we had been going to design it, a number of what’s within the comics wasn’t materials that we might or needed to make use of. However then it felt broad open, so I discovered the preliminary brainstorming on the street virtually too blue sky.

You’ve seemingly executed continuous work on two MCU options (Black Widow and Captain Marvel) and two MCU collection, so is that why you gave up Paul Bettany’s Imaginative and prescient Quest? Did you want a reprieve? 

Yeah, [Agatha All Along and Vision Quest] overlapped in a manner that wasn’t tenable for me, and it was with a really heavy coronary heart that I spotted that it logistically wouldn’t work for me. However I’m so wanting ahead to that present. I’m simply an infinite cheerleader for everyone concerned, particularly Paul.

Lastly, of your directorial work that’s aired to date, when did you most really feel the frenzy of being a director once more? 

It was day one on the pilot, largely as a result of these preliminary [Agnes of Westview] pictures in that episode are so opposite to every thing I’ve ever executed. I’ve by no means executed a moody drama or an atmospheric gritty factor earlier than, and once we had been shot itemizing the pictures I had in my head, I used to be like, “These really feel proper for another person.” We had been blessed on the day with this very gentle rain that triggered this stunning mist, and we didn’t have the know-how to make the feel look that good. If that had been our aim, we wouldn’t have been capable of do it ourselves, and it was only a reward. So the factor that existed in my mind turned even higher, and yeah, it was a rush.

***
Agatha All Alongside is at present streaming on Disney+.