The Framing of Kamala Harris

Pleased Thursday. We simply are hours away from Kamala Harris wrapping up the Democratic Nationwide Conference with the most important speech of her life. Right here’s what’s on our podium right this moment:

  • Important indicators: The ticking well being care time bomb
  • Bye-bye, asylum-seekers
  • Rail shutdown threatens provide traces
  • DNC vibes & partisan fervor
  • Plus: Brace your self for record-breaking hurricane season

However first, it’s Harris’ second to guide the Democratic Celebration, and what she does tonight will form the marketing campaign over the subsequent 75 days. What are her objectives? How will this arrange the remainder of the marketing campaign? And is probably the most stunning political battle of this cycle about which social gathering actually owns the phrase “freedom”?


Harris has three jobs as she takes over the ticket:

1. Unite the social gathering: Examine

Any thought there was lingering bitterness after Joe Biden was, um, Nancy Pelosi’ed to step down, has been banished. Harris has raised over $300 million and is presently fracking Bakken Formation–ranges of enthusiasm from what many thought had been dry Democratic wells.

Democrats will emerge from the conference — as Republicans did from the RNC — with massive momentum, flush with cash and a way of hope and risk that was nowhere to be seen when Biden was starring within the political model of “Thelma and Louise,” driving the social gathering off an electoral cliff.

Hope issues in politics as a result of it fuels volunteers to drive the get-out-the-vote machine, boosts fundraising, and resonates with key voting blocks like suburban ladies, Black and Latino voters, and younger individuals, the core of the blue machine.

Harris’ largest problem stays connecting with white, working, and middle-class male voters within the seven swing states. The gender hole is a major ingredient of the marketing campaign, and Democrats have been shedding these voters by the bale load. Enter vice presidential candidate Tim Walz, whose folksy pep rally speech final evening ditched just about any point out of his years in Congress in favor of specializing in his army service, his searching, and his soccer teaching profession. Walz doesn’t deliver a swing state like Pennsylvania with him, however he does deliver the common dad-in-flannel authenticity issue meant to maneuver middle-class and working-class males again to the Democratic Celebration.

2. Outline herself earlier than the opposition can outline her: Examine

Elections are about framing three sorts of narrative. First, body the narrative about your personal candidate, then body one round your opponent to create distinction, and, lastly, body the poll field query urging a name to motion.

The Obama of us used to name this Public Narrative idea, primarily based on the work of a man referred to as Marshall Ganz. The concept is to first inform the “story of self” — why you’re right here and what your function or mission is all about. Then inform the “story of us,” which is why all of us have a typical trigger within the mission, and finish the marketing campaign with a name to motion, the fierce urgency of the second, which Ganz calls the “the story of now.”

You may monitor the 4 days of the DNC by how they hit these three key goals, displaying that the Ganz e-book remains to be very a lot the DNA of the social gathering with Harris on the prime.

Harris is basically new as a presidential candidate, which implies she is balancing each the celebration of Biden’s report and taking credit score for its successes whereas distancing herself from it sufficient to introduce herself as an agent of change.

That is why she begins with the story of self. Paradoxically, Harris is helped by the truth that she was a considerably invisible vice chairman, even when she was very current on the abortion situation. Her lack of public persona started as a defend situation (Who’s she? What did she accomplish in three and half years?), however now it’s very a lot a sword. Harris is a clean slate, so her group has been in a position to outline her with the story of a joyful warrior, a protector, a prosecutor, and somebody who fights for the center class. Tonight, she is going to attempt to set that body in stone — after which put one across the Trump marketing campaign, as her operating mate, Tim Walz, began to do final evening. Trump as “bizarre,” Trump as “felon,” and Trump as solely about Trump.

The framing situation is bedeviling Trump, who till now has been a grasp at it. “Crooked Hillary.” “Sleepy Joe.” These adolescent nicknames have labored as a result of they’ve a hoop of reality for his viewers. Biden actually is, effectively, kinda sleepy. On Wednesday, Trump admitted he’s having a very arduous time making an attempt to border Harris. “I believe her identify shall be Comrade,” he stated, going off script. “As a result of that’s the most correct,” he continued, considering out loud. “You already know, I’ve been in search of a reputation, and folks have been saying, ‘Sir, don’t do it’ — you realize, all my names, they’ve all labored, they’ve all been very profitable — and I actually didn’t discover one along with her!”

Thus far, “Comrade Kamala” isn’t sticking, although the technique of calling her and Tim Walz radical communists is the playbook. However till Trump can determine one thing out, Harris has time to set her personal body.

Why hasn’t it labored for Trump?The “Commie” stuff is a stretch as a result of it’s not the Fifties anymore. The Purple Scare is generationally out of contact — and, apart from, it’s Trump who has nearer ties to Putin than the Democrats. Harris additionally has put out so little coverage to this point — a weak point in some ways however an asset on this occasion — that there isn’t any hook on which to hold the identify. In the meantime, the Harris group has adopted a form of “haters-gonna-hate, shake-it-off” vibe, and as an alternative of ignoring Trump (they’ve hopped off the “they go low, we go excessive” bandwagon), they’ve countered with a reputation of their very own: “Bizarre.”

Trump has managed to keep away from being outlined by opponents as a result of he’s at all times the one on offense, however the Harris of us have sidestepped him, successfully utilizing the acute elements of the Trump motion and his personal weird conspiracy theories to push him out of the mainstream and marginalize him. Proper now, she is successful the framing battle.

3. Set the poll field query: The hardest process forward for each Harris and Trump

That is the story of now, and what this marketing campaign is all about. Trump is relying on the salience of points like immigration, the economic system, safety, and the tradition wars in opposition to “woke-ism” to outline his marketing campaign. He’s again to his American carnage, “Après moi, le déluge” part. It’s ominous stuff, but it surely works for him, and he’s nonetheless very a lot in play on this election. However Trump’s assist isn’t rising. Harris is pushing points like abortion, anti-corporate greed, and anti-Trump to outline her marketing campaign. She desires the election to be about Trump as a result of Dems imagine he’s an more and more risky legal responsibility, particularly as he deepens his dive into conspiracy theories, feedback about her racial id, and easily lies about what he says are her AI-generated crowds.

There’s yet one more fascinating framing battle happening: the battle over the phrase “freedom.” Freedom has classically been the rallying cry of the correct — freedom from massive authorities, freedom to bear arms, freedom of the person in opposition to the tyranny of Massive Pharma, Massive Tech, the Deep State, and so forth. It’s the cornerstone of the victimization narrative and what’s alleged to underpin the “combat, combat, combat” rallying cry.

“The correct has historically owned patriotism and freedom in each its narrative and in how individuals view events on the correct or center-right,” pollster and CEO of Abacus Knowledge David Coletto advised me. “However I believe freedom seemingly means various things to totally different individuals, which is why I believe it’s good for the left to attempt to acquire some share again on it. That is very true within the US, the place abortion rights and freedom to make selections about one’s life are salient.”

That’s why the Democrats have overtly tried to yank again the phrase and flip the script. As you heard Walz final evening repeat his Minnesota slogan, “Thoughts your personal rattling enterprise,” the Dems argue that it’s Republicans who’re infringing on freedoms for girls and the LGBTQ neighborhood and infringing on the correct to well being care. On a extra meta stage, they’re arguing that Dems will defend the establishments which might be there to guard freedom — like safeguarding the US Capitol from an riot.

Whereas Biden centered his marketing campaign on the phrase “democracy,” beneath Harris, everybody from Walz and Oprah to Obama to Shapiro to Buttigieg has made certain the phrase “freedom” has been entrance and heart. A currentWashington Publish article identified that “at 100 marketing campaign occasions since launching his reelection in April 2023, Biden referenced “democracy” 386 occasions and “freedom” about 175 occasions. By comparability, in 9 marketing campaign rallies since Biden dropped out, Harris referenced “freedom” almost 60 occasions and “democracy” round a dozen.

“The combat over the phrase issues,” says Coletto. “Because the world has turn out to be extra insecure, and as individuals witness the return of authoritarianism, we’re much less more likely to take freedom as a right. I believe the idea is on the ascendency once more as individuals distinction their very own lives and the way they need to dwell with how they see others residing in much less free nations.”

At this second, who protects freedom and who curtails it isn’t the poll query — seemingly the economic system will nonetheless be the decider for independents — however the freedom debate is the proxy warfare right here.

As she speaks tonight, count on Kamala Harris to attempt to grasp the “freedom” body across the marketing campaign.