Vice President Harris is pictured throughout an interview with CNN’s Dana Bash in Savannah, Ga., on Thursday — her first in-depth, on-the-record dialog with a journalist since changing into the Democratic presidential nominee.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
disguise caption
toggle caption
Will Lanzoni/CNN
Vice President Harris sat for her first interview Thursday evening since getting into the presidential race 5 weeks in the past. It was joint along with her operating mate, Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, however she did a lot of the speaking.
The interview, carried out by CNN’s Dana Bash on the marketing campaign path in Georgia, was seen as an vital step in what’s been a extremely profitable – and extremely scripted – marketing campaign so far.
So how did she do? Listed below are six takeaways:
1. Harris handed the take a look at of doing an unscripted interview
From a strictly efficiency standpoint, Harris was clear, calm and didn’t get rattled when pushed about modifications to her positions on sure points.
In some previous interviews, she got here throughout as defensive, however that wasn’t the case right here. She appeared comfy and in command, which is vital for a presidential candidate who individuals are nonetheless attending to know.
She additionally continued to point out a level of relatability. For instance, she talked about making pancakes and cooking bacon for her nieces when President Biden known as to tell her of his determination to drop out of the race.
2. Democrats are doubtless respiration a sigh of reduction about how Harris will do in a debate, however there’s some cleansing as much as do
Debates are sometimes about optics and never substance, which the primary debate between Biden and former President Donald Trump confirmed. On this interview, when Bash pushed Harris on some place modifications, Harris confirmed she’s largely in a position to parry assaults adequately.
Harris and her group will most likely wish to clear up her response as to why she modified her place on fracking, although, and stick with one thing clearer. Merely saying, “My values haven’t modified,” doubtless gained’t suffice. Politicians can change positions, however folks anticipate to listen to why in a plausible means.
Harris did give a believable cause for switching from being in opposition to fracking to in favor of it.
“What I’ve seen is that we will develop, and we will enhance a clear vitality financial system with out banning fracking,” she mentioned about what’s a politically potent problem in Pennsylvania, perhaps essentially the most intently watched swing state. She famous that she forged the tie-breaking vote in Congress for increasing fracking leases.
However it took her some time to make that time, and it may not be what most individuals see in clips of the interview within the coming days.
As a substitute, when Harris was first requested in regards to the change on this interview, she initially mentioned her place hadn’t modified from 2020. That’s as a result of within the 2020 vice-presidential debate, Harris did say twice that “Joe Biden won’t finish fracking. He has been very clear about that.”
However that’s splitting the hair too finely. In 2019, when she was operating for president herself, she mentioned throughout a CNN city corridor centered on local weather change: “There’s no query I’m in favor of banning fracking and beginning with what we will do on Day 1 round public lands.”
When she joined Biden’s ticket, she deserted that place and is now pledging to stay in favor of it.
3. Harris exhibits (once more) she’s not an ideologue — and is aiming for the center
Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz and Vice President Harris are interviewed by CNN’s Dana Bash at Kim’s Cafe in Savannah, Ga., on Thursday.
Will Lanzoni/CNN
disguise caption
toggle caption
Will Lanzoni/CNN
From saying she would appoint a Republican to her Cupboard to committing to stronger fracking and immigration insurance policies than she had in 2019, to her place on Israel, Harris is once more displaying she’s aiming her marketing campaign squarely on the center.
A bigger level on her transfer to the middle on fracking and immigration specifically is that these shifts monitor with one thing she’s been constant on — and one thing that introduced her criticism in 2019: She believes most in fixing issues.
“I consider you will need to construct consensus, and you will need to discover a frequent place of understanding of the place we will truly remedy issues,” Harris informed Bash.
She shared that sentiment 5 years in the past.
“[I]s my authorities fixing issues?” Harris informed NPR’s Scott Detrow in 2019 of what she sees as most vital in public service. “That is how I give it some thought. And it is the best way I’ve at all times judged myself, frankly, and my work, which is – are we related, proper? … It is about, each day, are we addressing folks’s real-life issues and fixing them? And albeit, if we’re not, we have to transfer over.”
In 2019, that didn’t fly, as a result of progressives needed a champion, they usually had been already cautious of Harris’ document as California’s lawyer basic and San Francisco district lawyer, which they thought-about too reasonable.
Conservatives on this election have been going after Harris for what they see as inauthenticity, however the factor that Harris has at all times proven is that she’s pragmatic. She’s been a lot clearer on the place she stands on this marketing campaign than she was in 2019 – and that’s aimed immediately on the center.
That features whereas on the marketing campaign path in Georgia Thursday, saying that one among her high priorities might be serving to small companies and promising to roll out a tax credit score proposal for brand spanking new small companies subsequent week.
The underside line is: Harris is a giant D Democrat. She may wish to transfer the nation to the left of the place Donald Trump needs to take it, however she’s signaling that, as president, like former President Barack Obama earlier than her, she would most likely be as liberal as Congress and her coalition will permit her to be.
Frankly, this line of assault that her stances maintain altering may stick extra to Harris if she wasn’t operating in opposition to Trump.
4. We did get some clearer coverage concepts
Requested what she would do on Day 1, Harris mentioned she would search for methods to “strengthen” the center class and begin attempting to implement her “Alternative Financial system” plan she laid out final week to carry costs down and attempt to make houses extra inexpensive.
Particularly, Harris talked on this interview about:
- Extending a $6,000 little one tax credit score to households for first yr of a kid’s life, and her
- A $25,000 first-time homebuyer tax credit score
She has famous different proposals in the midst of this truncated marketing campaign, like eager to attempt to cross the John Lewis voting rights invoice, which Republicans have blocked, and eager to revive the border-security invoice Biden drafted with conservative Republicans that Trump opposed and the GOP-led Home then killed.
Harris has been dinged for not placing ahead deep coverage proposals, however no candidate campaigns efficiently as a strolling coverage memo.
Campaigns do often roll out coverage papers that embrace value analyses and the like, and Harris hasn’t carried out that, however neither has Trump in a critical means.
Plus, presidential campaigns are actually about huge concepts and what course a candidate needs to take the nation, particularly on this election, when folks have such sturdy and ingrained emotions about Trump.
5. Harris didn’t run from “Bidenomics”
Some may need thought that Harris would attempt to put distance between herself and Biden’s financial insurance policies, given how negatively People view the financial system presently – regardless of pretty sturdy development, low unemployment and a decline in inflation previously yr.
Trump can also be out with an advert this week hitting Harris on this very matter, evaluating what she’s mentioned at completely different instances about what’s develop into generally known as “Bidenomics.”
However as a substitute of shying away from it, Harris defended Biden’s financial insurance policies, arguing “mismanagement” from Trump in the course of the COVID pandemic gave them a less-than-optimal hand. She identified what she feels the administration has carried out properly, from capping prescription drug prices for seniors and chopping little one poverty, to a rise in manufacturing jobs and enhancing provide chains.
“I’ll say that that’s good work,” Harris mentioned. “There’s extra to do, however that’s good work.”
It was a robust protection, displaying off how she may rebut the critique on the upcoming debate. However it additionally exhibits what a whole lot of Democrats have been crying out for – somebody to make the case on the financial system properly, as a substitute of how Biden typically responded, which got here off as him taking the assaults personally and appearing defensively.
Harris leaning into the argument that the administration has made progress – whether or not it really works or not – can also be a reminder that politics isn’t at all times about doing one thing as a result of it’s already widespread; it’s attempting to really win the argument, one thing Democrats weren’t doing with Biden on the high of the ticket.
Polls have proven that voters have given Harris the advantage of the doubt on the financial system and haven’t tied her to damaging emotions about it the best way they did with Biden. We’ll see how public opinion strikes, if in any respect, following the Democratic conference, this interview, Trump’s advert blitz and the upcoming debate.
6. Harris once more stayed centered on her agenda and didn’t take the (race) bait on Trump
Bash additionally requested Harris about Trump’s inflammatory feedback about her race and ethnicity. In July, Trump mentioned to a gathering of Black journalists, “I didn’t know she was Black till plenty of years in the past when she occurred to show Black and now she needs to be generally known as Black. So, I don’t know, is she Indian or is she Black?”
Right here was Harris’ response Thursday evening:
HARRIS: “Yeah.”
BASH: “Any—”
HARRIS: “Standard, drained playbook.” [Pause] Subsequent query, please.” [Laugh]
BASH: “That’s it?”
HARRIS: “That’s it.”
Later within the interview, she mentioned: “I’m operating as a result of I consider that I’m one of the best particular person to do that job at this second for all People, no matter race and gender.”
Throughout this marketing campaign, Harris hasn’t dwelled on the historic nature of her candidacy. It’s a tough line for a Black candidate when one is attempting to enchantment to white voters within the center. It’s difficult for a lady operating for president in a rustic that has by no means elected a girl to the White Home.
However Harris has been deft at disregarding Trump’s makes an attempt to tug her into controversies he’s created.
Her calm in opposition to Trump’s tumult is a side-by-side image Democrats are banking on.
“The break up display screen works so properly for her and Democrats proper now,” mentioned Joel Payne, a Democratic strategist and chief communications officer for MoveOn Political Motion. “The chaos vs. stability argument that the Biden marketing campaign was attempting to execute in opposition to Trump, the Harris group is ready to do it with a lot extra effectiveness.”