Despite the awful season he just had, no one is denying that Justin Jefferson is one of the most talented wide receivers in the NFL. That makes the Minnesota Vikings WR1 a classic case of how much to weigh talent vs. situation vs. opportunity. Can the quarterback upgrade from JJ McCarthy to Kyler Murray restore Jefferson’s status as an elite WR1?
Should You Draft Justin Jefferson in Fantasy Football?
Let’s start this assessment with the most basic of fantasy stats: fantasy points per game. Here are Jefferson’s PPG by season:
Advertisement
Suffice it to say…one of these things is not like the other.
START PREPARING: PFN’s Fantasy Mock Draft Simulator
We’ve seen elite wide receivers throughout history post down years. It happens. But perennial top-five wide receivers almost never suddenly finish outside the top 36. Technically, Jefferson was the WR28 in PPG. However, 2025 was a down year for wide receiver scoring. Using historical thresholds, 12 PPG is typically around WR36. Jefferson was one of the worst picks you could’ve made in 2025.
It goes without saying that Jefferson is not a player in decline or suddenly bad at football. Nothing about his part of the equation really changed.
Advertisement
Jefferson saw a 30.3% target share. He was targeted on 26.9% of his routes run. Amazingly, he still managed to hit 2.0 yards per route run, which, although not a great result for him, is mighty impressive under the circumstances.
There were two specific areas in Jefferson’s raw production that lagged behind his career norms. His yards per reception had never been under 14.1 before the 2025 season. It was just 12.5. That is how he caught 84 passes, but just barely cracked 1,000 yards. For context, in 2023, the year in which Jefferson missed seven games with a hamstring strain, he had more receiving yards than he did in all 17 games last year.
The other area in which Jefferson struggled was touchdowns. His previous career low was the seven he scored as a rookie (he scored five in the aforementioned 2023 season, but obviously that extrapolates to more than seven across a full 17 games). Last year, Jefferson scored just twice. So, what do we do with Jefferson this year and going forward?
Advertisement
Jefferson’s Redraft Fantasy Football Value
Jefferson is no longer in contention to be one of the top three wide receivers off the board. That’s now reserved for Ja’Marr Chase, Puka Nacua, and Jaxon Smith-Njigba. But he is firmly in the next group featuring Amon-Ra St. Brown and CeeDee Lamb. Even so, a WR6 and a Round 1 ADP is mighty rich for a player who, if we were redrafting the 2025 season today, would barely crack the top 10 rounds.
Obviously, the major change for the Vikings this season is signing Kyler Murray. But is he the answer to all of Jefferson’s problems? After all, this is a former No. 1 overall pick whom the Arizona Cardinals decided to move on from because he wasn’t good enough.
MORE: 2026 Controversial Fantasy Football Running Back Depth Charts: Who To Draft In These Confusing Rooms
Advertisement
Murray has always been overrated as a real-life quarterback, which may be due in large part to the expectations of being the top pick. He was a massive fade last season, and that worked out. But has the hate gone too far?
The general consensus seems to be that Murray is barely an NFL-caliber starting quarterback, at best. That seems a bit harsh. Murray is pretty confidently one of the 32 best quarterbacks in the world. Will he ever play at a level corresponding with being a No. 1 overall pick? Probably not. But can he be serviceable? Absolutely.
Murray’s fantasy production is not what’s at issue here, but it is relevant for context. Prior to last year’s injury-shortened season that limited him to five games, Murray had never averaged fewer than 17.8 PPG.
STAY UPDATED: PFN’s Fantasy News Tracker
Advertisement
Although it was several years ago, Murray was able to support WR1 production from DeAndre Hopkins and Hollywood Brown. So, there is precedent for WR1 producing with Murray at quarterback. He’s still just 29 years old.
Prior to last season, Jefferson was perceived as being QB-proof. This was due in large part to his ability to maintain WR1-level production in 2024 after Kirk Cousins tore his Achilles while catching passes from the likes of Nick Mullens, Josh Dobbs, and Jaren Hall. In fact, McCarthy is the only quarterback Jefferson was unable to produce with. Here are his career splits:
-
With JJ McCarthy: 11.0 PPG
-
With anyone else: 18.9 PPG
Murray may not be as effective of a passer as prime Cousins, but he certainly belongs more in the “anyone else” bucket.
I have Jefferson at WR6. At that price, fantasy managers probably aren’t drafting him. But having him firmly in WR1 territory establishes I believe in a bounce back for one of the most talented players in the NFL.
Advertisement
Jefferson’s Dynasty Fantasy Football Value
In Dynasty, there’s even less of a concern about Jefferson. At 27 years old, he’s firmly in the prime of his career and at no risk of beginning his decline for at least another three years, but more likely 5-6.
TRADE NOW: PFN’s Dynasty Trade Calculator
Even if Murray isn’t the answer at quarterback, one of two things will happen beginning in 2027. Either McCarthy will take a step forward and be able to feed Jefferson at the level Kevin O’Connell expects, or there will be someone new not currently on the roster (or perhaps even in the NFL). Either way, fantasy managers should have confidence in KOC installing a signal caller who can get the ball to his team’s best player.
Advertisement
We have Jefferson at WR4 in our dynasty rankings. The reality is this is a player who has been a consensus top-five dynasty-wide receiver for the past half-decade. He showed no signs of any talent issues last season. It was purely situational. In dynasty, we try not to overweigh the situation. If the Jefferson manager in your league is feeling tentative, now might be the time to try and pry him away.
This article originally appeared on Pro Football Network.