It’s a hotly contested race that includes a former feminine prosecutor and a person credibly accused of sexual harassment, with the way forward for regulation and order on the poll.
No, it’s not the presidential race.
However that description suits the competition for Macomb County prosecutor that pits incumbent Republican Pete Lucido, a former state senator, towards Democratic challenger Christina Hines, a former prosecutor in each Wayne and Washtenaw counties, who now serves as an adjunct regulation professor at Wayne State College.
“Lots of people have form of commented on the truth that I’ve a really comparable race that Kamala Harris does,“ Hines advised the Michigan Advance. “It’s a youthful prosecutor who truly has this expertise, who’s operating towards a MAGA Republican that shouldn’t have been in workplace within the first place.”
Lucido received election to the publish in 2020, with former President Donald Trump scoring large on the high of the ticket in Macomb County. Though Lucido was weighed down by appreciable controversy coming into the workplace — and has courted it since — he’s nonetheless thought-about the favourite in a county that’s grown redder and Trump will, as soon as once more, be on the poll.
A observe document of ‘credible’ accusations
In January 2020, whereas Lucido served as a Republican state senator, a number of allegations of sexual harassment got here to mild, starting with an inappropriate trade involving a former Michigan Advance reporter. Lucido apologized in a tweet the next day for the “misunderstanding” and for “offending” the reporter, however he went on to vary his story a number of instances in media interviews, together with in March 2020, when he claimed that he hadn’t “sexually harassed anybody.”
That incident prompted state Sen. Mallory McMorrow (D-Royal Oak), to file a formal sexual harassment criticism about Lucido with the Senate Enterprise Workplace regarding an encounter in November 2018 throughout a brand new senator orientation occasion in Lansing. Melissa Osborn, a regulatory and legislative affairs specialist for the Michigan Credit score Union League, mentioned that Lucido harassed her throughout a convention in Lansing in 2019.
A Senate Enterprise Workplace investigation in March 2020 concluded that every one three girls have been “credible” of their accusations and that the incidents “extra seemingly than not” occurred as reported by every accuser. Because of this, then-Senate Majority Chief Mike Shirkey (R-Clarklake) eliminated Lucido from his place as chair of the influential Senate Recommendation and Consent Committee and required him to take part in further coaching. Regardless of that, Lucido falsely claimed he’d been exonerated.
The Advance made a number of requests for remark to Lucido for this story, however he didn’t reply.
Hines argues that Lucido’s historical past is related to the election.
“An individual with a document of sexual harassment shouldn’t be prosecutor,” mentioned Hines, who grew up in Warren and lives there now along with her husband and three youngsters.
As a resident, she mentioned she has watched the prosecutor’s workplace descend ever deeper into dysfunction, starting with former Prosecutor Eric Smith, a Democrat, who resigned in 2020 after being charged with embezzlement, ended up serving seven months in jail, earlier than pleading responsible final 12 months to state counts together with misconduct in workplace, for which he was sentenced to 4 years of probation.
With Smith’s resignation opening the door for Lucido, he efficiently received election to the publish in November 2020, however shortly bumped into comparable points that had created headlines for him as a state senator.
A 2022 report commissioned by Macomb County discovered that as prosecutor, Lucido acted offensively towards feminine staff, along with his habits described as “impolite,” “curt,” “unprofessional” and “brutal.”
The report really helpful that Lucido, who refused to cooperate with the investigation, be supplied with coaching regarding the Elliott-Larsen Civil Rights Act and associated Macomb County insurance policies.
“Pete Lucido failed his first try on the Macomb County Harassment and Anti-Discrimination coaching, scoring solely 64.7%. Months later, Pete Lucido lastly handed the coaching, scoring 82.35% – passing by solely 2.35%,” mentioned Hines in a press launch.
Lucido can also be combating an ethics criticism filed earlier this 12 months by elections legal professional Mark Brewer, former chair of the Michigan Democratic Social gathering, alleging he allowed county property for use for political marketing campaign functions.
Lucido later filed a lawsuit towards Macomb County’s company counsel and ethics board, claiming they violated state regulation by assembly in closed session. The matter stays pending.
Lucido’s path to prosecutor
Based on his marketing campaign web site, Lucido, additionally a lifelong Macomb County resident, graduated in 1988 from Detroit School of Regulation, now often called Michigan State College School of Regulation.
Lucido based his personal regulation agency, Lucido and Manzella, the place he practiced till politics referred to as to him. In 2014, he was elected as a state consultant for the thirty sixth District, serving two phrases, till he moved as much as the state Senate in 2018, representing the eighth District. He resigned from that place after simply two years following his election as Macomb County prosecutor in November 2020.
Lucido says that since then, he has “cleaned up the Prosecutor’s Workplace, made it extra environment friendly, introduced full transparency and equity, and continues to guard these all through Macomb County.”
In a January interview with the Oakland Put up, the coed newspaper of his undergraduate alma mater, Oakland College, Lucido was requested about his favourite features of the job.
“I get to satisfy individuals, not a lot in the perfect conditions and eventualities, and I assist them to progress and get closure of their life from issues which have occurred,” Lucido mentioned. “Nobody ever stood up and mentioned they wished to be a sufferer. So after I meet the victims for the primary time, I’ve to be sympathetic to the truth that they didn’t need this to occur. They’re going by way of a tough time, and likewise that we get them on the street to restoration the perfect we will.”
Lucido advised the Oakland Put up that he was pleased with his document as prosecutor.
“I’ve began new items and created new strategies of dealing with prison justice. I’ve been round prison justice actually all my life. That’s the one job I ever actually had,” he mentioned.
Based on Lucido’s marketing campaign mailers, he desires to “improve and broaden our specialty courts for non-violent offenders,” create a “Public Corruption And Integrity Unit,” and stay robust on crime, saying “offenders might be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the regulation. There might be No Hugs For Thugs.”
A ‘mild bulb second’
Hines mentioned she was initially reluctant when approached to tackle Lucido.
“Like a whole lot of girls, I form of needed to be talked into truly making this run as a result of I’ve acquired three little youngsters and thought that I might be a greater mother if I used to be taking good care of my youngsters extra and never operating this loopy marketing campaign,” mentioned Hines.
Nonetheless, an incident in January 2023 compelled her to rethink the concept.
“It was truly when Pete Lucido made that Fb publish about celebrating Accomplice Basic [Robert E.] Lee,” mentioned Hines. “My husband is Black. I’ve three little Black youngsters at dwelling. And so it was simply that basically mild bulb second of realizing that if I did truly need to shield my youngsters, if I did need to actually shield our group, I wanted to run.”
Hines says she’s knocked on over 5,000 doorways up to now within the marketing campaign, whereas elevating greater than $200,000.
“I’ve united the Macomb County Democratic Social gathering. I’ve acquired [Macomb County Executive] Mark Hackel supporting me.”
Hackel’s endorsement is notable in that whereas he’s a Democrat, his assist for different Democrats isn’t one thing provided reflexively, having beforehand endorsed Republicans together with Macomb County Public Works Commissioner Candice Miller, and Macomb County Clerk Anthony Forlini.
“I’m proud to endorse Christina Hines for Macomb County Prosecutor,” mentioned Hackel. “Not solely as a result of she is the one candidate with prosecutorial expertise, however as a result of she has persistently demonstrated the power to carry offenders accountable whereas successfully working with regulation enforcement and group companions.”
It’s additionally no secret that Hackel has not been a fan of Lucido, as witnessed earlier this 12 months when he mentioned Lucido had tried to deflect blame after the prosecutor’s workplace did not publicize high-profile fees that had been introduced towards two Warren law enforcement officials.
Hines went a step additional and accused Lucido of not being truthful in regards to the incident.
“When prosecutors lie and conceal data within the title of politics, it causes hypothesis and uninformed commentary that undermines the belief our group has in regulation enforcement, prosecutors, and our broader justice system.”
Getting in hassle
Hines earned her regulation diploma from Wayne State College in 2014 after interning within the U.S. Lawyer’s Workplace for the Japanese District of Michigan, the place she mentioned it grew to become clear she wished to not solely be a prosecutor, however prosecute sexual assault instances.
“After I graduated, I began working on the Wayne County Prosecutor’s Workplace, however I acquired in hassle on my third day within the workplace,” mentioned Hines, laughing. “I used to be form of sneaking over to the sexual assault unit as a result of I wished to assist these prosecutors though I used to be typically crimes; robberies and weapons and medicines and stuff like that. I say I acquired in hassle, however they provided me the full-time union place, not a contract place. And I believe a whole lot of that was due to initiative and work ethic and my ardour for it.”
That keenness was apparent to Hines’ boss, Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy.
“She’s a really proficient and really passionate prosecutor,” Worthy advised the Advance. “She was particularly proficient when it got here to points of kids and ladies and SVU, particular victims. That’s what I might be taught to be her specialty …. She was very, excellent.”
Worthy mentioned that Hines shortly had some concepts of adjustments she wished to make when it got here to sexual assault prosecution, which her workplace ultimately applied.
“She was very involved in regards to the wellness and the psychological well being of people that did that work on daily basis,” mentioned Worthy. “She was taken with being proactive and having issues for the workers to do to assist them with what we now know as secondary trauma. Nevertheless it was due to her…that I began taking the workplace in that path. And so we do a whole lot of wellness and preventative issues now for our workers.”
Following her six years with the Wayne County Prosecutor’s Workplace, Hines went to Washtenaw County to work underneath Prosecutor Eli Savit, after he received election there in 2020. Hines grew to become chief of each the Particular Victims Unit and the Appellate, Coaching and Forfeiture Models.
Savit was elected as a part of a wave of so-called progressive prosecutors championing insurance policies that included eliminating the usage of money bail, making Washtenaw County the primary jurisdiction in Michigan to take action.
Nonetheless, Hines says it’s not one thing that she sees as sensible.
“Savit is nice, and he was doing the issues that I believe the group wished and making an attempt to maneuver in that path,” she mentioned. “What I noticed personally is that it didn’t work. Judges weren’t on board. And one factor about any sort of recent thought is that you just want group assist and also you want stakeholder buy-in, and the truth that the judges aren’t essentially on board for it actually tousled the plan.”
Hines says a prosecutor’s prime motivation should be public security, and in instances of bail, the query must be whether or not or not that particular person will present up for court docket once more.
“My opinion is that if somebody is harmful, I don’t care who they’re, and I don’t care how a lot cash they make. They need to be in jail pending trial. If somebody isn’t a hazard, then we must always be capable of work out different circumstances that can make them keep,” she mentioned.
Hines mentioned she doesn’t think about herself a progressive prosecutor, and desires to place knowledge earlier than politics.
“So, the progressive, the Democratic, Republican aspect of these things, once we’re speaking about public security, I believe that it’s past get together,” she mentioned. “It’s past these kinds of ideologies. It’s about what does knowledge say? What does widespread sense say? What does our group want?”
That distinction, nevertheless, didn’t deter the far-right Conservative Political Motion Coalition (CPAC) from operating an commercial concentrating on Hines, alleging she is funded by “left-wing billionaire George Soros” who has spent “tens of tens of millions to elect tender on crime prosecutors” together with in Ann Arbor.
Hines believes the advert says much more about her opponent than it does her.
“There are just a few severely contested giant DA/Prosecutor races within the nation, not to mention in a swing state. Ours is considered one of them,” she mentioned “Both means, I believe it reveals the correct is nervous that Lucido goes to lose.”
The No. 1 job of a prosecutor
Hines says her motivation to interchange Lucido is about extra than simply his character, though she says his character ties on to a “tradition and integrity drawback” within the workplace.
On the high of the record of issues is the shortage of trials in a county the dimensions of Macomb. Though it’s the third largest in Michigan, she says there have been much less jury trials there than Kent County, which has 200,000 fewer residents.
“To begin with, our prosecutor’s workplace has turn into only a plea deal capital of Michigan. We’ve much less jury trials than the variety of assistant prosecutors in our workplace,” mentioned Hines, who believes Lucido’s overreliance on plea offers is an issue that may truly make a group much less protected in the long term.
Lucido, nevertheless, has mentioned the difficulty isn’t so easy. Throughout a candidates’ discussion board hosted in July by the Macomb County NAACP, he mentioned there merely isn’t the structural skill to strive each case.
“You have got causes and causes why sure of the victims don’t need to go to court docket, don’t need to go to trial, and also you attempt to go forward and ensure the system is equally honest too as a result of you need to steadiness what the sufferer desires, what the officers need in accord with what it’s that you just’re going to satisfy the ends of justice,” he mentioned. “I do know that there’s plea bargains on the market, however don’t take it out on the prosecutor. Take it out on simply the best way the system is overloaded and burdened.”
Hines says one other situation is excessive turnover of workers inside the prosecutor’s workplace underneath Lucido.
“Nearly half the workplace has left — investigators, sufferer advocates, [assistant prosecuting attorneys], everyone,” she mentioned, additionally noting that Lucido blamed understaffing for a delayed warrant request in 2022 that left a suspect on the streets who authorities say later shot and killed a Detroit Police officer.
“I believe it’s simply form of a shocking instance of: This man doesn’t know the way to do that job, and he doesn’t actually need to do that work,” she mentioned.
Hines says she asks voters to contemplate who might be a greater prosecutor for them — somebody like herself with years of trial expertise or Lucido, who she claims has by no means tried a case as a prosecutor.
“My background is so nice for the kind of voter that basically does care about public security, as a result of I’ve been a baby abuse and sexual assault prosecutor. I’ve dealt with human trafficking instances. I labored on programming to maintain youngsters protected on-line with the Michigan State Police. These are the problems that folks actually care about proper now in Macomb County.”
Hines left her job as First Assistant Washtenaw County Prosecutor in January to give attention to the Macomb County race, saying she wanted to commit “100% on the marketing campaign.”
That focus is one thing Worthy thinks says quite a bit about why Hines would make a superb prosecutor.
“I believe what she did was a daring transfer, placing all of it on the road for one thing that she thinks is the correct factor to do and that she’s higher suited to, and meaning quite a bit to me,” mentioned Worthy. “Christina doesn’t have an agenda. She desires to do that work.”
GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX