We’re about three weeks away from the 2026 Heisman ceremony. Here’s a look at the current Heisman race leaders and who could end up in New York as a finalist.
Top 5 Heisman candidates
No. 1 — WR Jeremiah Smith | Ohio State
Jeremiah Smith was the Heisman favorite before Julian Sayin went down with an injury, and even without his starting quarterback, he’s been putting up big numbers. Smith has back-to-back 100-plus-yard games as Ohio State remains in playoff contention.
If Smith keeps putting up big numbers, he should make it to New York regardless of whether Ohio State’s quarterback issues lead to wins.
No. 2 — QB CJ Carr | Notre Dame
CJ Carr’s Heisman moment might’ve come in the first half against then-No. 1 Miami, when he threw three touchdowns to keep Notre Dame’s CFP hopes alive. Yet even that felt a bit underwhelming, as it wasn’t flashy, despite the great numbers.
Nonetheless, Carr has Notre Dame 9-1 and in the hunt for a top-five CFP ranking. That could lead Carr to New York as a finalist.
No. 3 — QB Darian Mensah | Miami (Fla.)
A quarterback has won the Heisman in 21 of the last 26 years, as the position has dominated the award since the turn of the century. Darian Mensah might be the top QB in contention to keep the dominance alive in 2026.
Mensah leads the FBS in completion percentage, ranks second in touchdowns and fifth in passing yards. He’s thrown only two interceptions this season.
He also plays for a Miami team in College Football Playoff and ACC title contention. He’s gotten a boost in Heisman odds after Malachi Toney went out, despite a slow start in a loss to Notre Dame.
With a strong finish to the season, Mensah is likely to end up in New York.
No. 4 — QB Devon Dampier | Utah
Devon Dampier has Utah undefeated, doing it in the air and on the ground. He has 22 passing touchdowns and nine rushing touchdowns.
While Dampier hasn’t had the season-long hype of others in the Heisman race, he’s been a late riser in the after scoring four total touchdowns in each of his last two games against ranked opponents. As long as Utah keeps winning, Dampier remains an intriguing option to end up in New York.
No. 5 — RB Nate Sheppard | Duke
Nate Sheppard has played like the best running back in the country. It showed in a loss to ACC-leader Miami, where he rushed for 131 yards and two touchdowns while catching 12 passes for 93 yards. Sheppard leads the nation in rushing touchdowns by a running back and ranks second in rushing yardage.
With games against Clemson and Wake Forest to close the season, Sheppard could be the reason his team wins and prove why he deserves an invite to New York.
Good QBs on good teams, but not outstanding yet
No. 6 — QB Gunner Stockton | Georgia
Has Gunner Stockton played outstanding? At times, yes. He threw four touchdowns and rushed for another against Ole Miss. Yet, even that performance didn’t feel Heisman-esque, as he threw for only 186 yards.
Stockton will remain in the Heisman race as the starting quarterback on the No. 1 team in the country, but he’ll need a performance that jumps off the screen if he’s going to finish as a finalist.
No. 7 — QB Gio Lopez | Wake Forest
Gio Lopez has Wake Forest’s offense playing at an elite level right now. The Demon Deacons have the No. 2 offense in the FBS, and he’s thrown 19 touchdowns to just one interception. That one interception came in Wake Forest’s only loss to Miami.
Lopez’s numbers aren’t yet Heisman-level, but recent performances have him rising up the charts. Lopez will have to hope for revenge against the Hurricanes in the ACC Championship Game for a shot at making it to New York.
No. 8 — QB Keelon Russell | Alabama
Keelon Russell has Alabama at No. 3 in the College Football Playoff Rankings, but his performances in losses to Georgia and Tennessee still stand out. If he gets a chance at redemption in the SEC Championship Game, that could be a late boost to get him to New York.
Unlikely
No. 9 — RB DeSean Bishop | Tennessee
- Bishop has been the best player on Tennessee this season, but he’s only seventh nationally in rushing yards and ninth in rushing touchdowns. Tennessee also doesn’t have any ranked opponents remaining, so it would need to make the SEC Championship Game for Bishop to steal the spotlight.
No. 10 — WR Jesse Legree | Oregon State
- Legree’s Beavers have lost three straight games and won’t play a game with high stakes the rest of the way.
No. 11 — QB Drew Mestemaker | Oklahoma State
- Mestemaker leads the FBS in passing yards, but he didn’t play spectacularly against Texas Tech. That could’ve been his Heisman moment, but he missed it.
No. 12 — WR Malachi Toney | Miami (Fla.)
- Malachi Toney was in Heisman contention until an ankle injury. That injury keeps him out of Heisman contention, but he could still receive some votes.
