[This story contains spoilers for Prime Video’s We Were Liars.]
After the We Have been Liars e book was launched in 2014, writer E. Lockhart had a bestseller. However now greater than a decade later, the writer’s YA novel in regards to the prosperous Sinclair household who spend each summer time on Beechwood, a rich fictional island off of Martha’s Winery, has garnered new consideration because of social media and TikTok aesthetic movies, and now a Prime Video collection adaptation starring Emily Alyn Lind, Esther McGregor, Shubham Maheshwari and Joseph Zada (who notably scored the lead function within the upcoming Starvation Video games prequel Dawn on the Reaping as Haymitch.)
All through the eight-episode collection from showrunners Julie Plec and Carina Adly MacKenzie, the story follows Lind’s Cadence try and course of a tragedy that occurred on the Sinclair’s Beechwood residence whereas affected by amnesia. As Cadence tries to piece collectively the occasions that unfolded that evening, the secrets and techniques of her household and tight-knit liars involves mild. The present, which highlights themes of wealth, social class, love and household abides by the e book’s formulation of alternating between flashbacks and the current time, whereas resulting in a twist that, to today, continues to stun readers.
“Generally they had been throwing the e book throughout the room. Generally they had been weeping copiously, and snot was dripping out of their nostril and mascaras operating on their face. The essence of these responses was, WTF, this e book?” Lockhart tells The Hollywood Reporter about fan reactions to her story.
Amid the present’s launch, Lockhart talks about serving to convey her e book to life onscreen, writing the finale and the way the twist requires followers of the present to “lie” in true Liars style.
Earlier than speaking in regards to the present, I wished to return to writing the e book. You’ve got a doctorate in English literature from Columbia College (particularly the Nineteenth-century British novel). How did that result in writing a YA fiction novel?
After I went to Columbia, I imagined that what I used to be going to do was learn a number of Dickens and Bronte, different wonderful writers from the Nineteenth and early twentieth century and sort of be immersed on this world of unpacking fiction and understanding it in deep methods. And that was a part of it, however it was an age of large deal with deconstruction, post-colonial principle. It was not that lengthy into my doctoral work, once I realized that what I’d do once I completed was educate school without end. Instantly I believed, Oh, my goodness, I’ve made a mistake. And I spotted that what I wished to do was be telling these tales. I wished to grasp fiction making, and so I began writing creatively whereas I used to be in graduate faculty. I actually by no means went on the job market. As an alternative, I started to inform tales myself.
We Have been Liars was first revealed in 2014 and regardless of it being a while, the e book has seemingly gotten a brand new life by way of social media. What was that new consideration like?
We Have been Liars was my best-selling e book when it first got here out, after which, because it at all times occurs, it was now not a bestseller, and I went on to jot down different novels. After which in 2020, after we had been all dwelling by means of the pandemic, Tiktok creators began making a brand new sort of e book advice video that was very thrilling and really artistic. So as a substitute of merely saying, “Hey, right here’s a e book I like. Perhaps you prefer to it too and right here’s why,” they had been making aesthetic movies that introduced readers into the world of this privately owned island off the coast of Massachusetts with photos of children leaping off cliffs to go swimming and bonfires on the seashore and summer time love and all of that. The opposite sort of movies they made had been very weak movies of themselves studying the ending to the novel and responding to it. And typically they had been throwing the e book throughout the room. Generally they had been weeping copiously, and snot was dripping out of their nostril and mascaras operating on their face. The essence of these responses was, WTF, this e book? And so folks had been both exercising their artistic [outlet] or sharing their vulnerability. I felt very fortunate that my e book was one in every of a number of that bought that sort of consideration.
Was there any fascinating commentary in regards to the story that you simply discover now that sort of shocked you, or had been fascinating to you that possibly you hadn’t considered earlier than when the e book was first launched?
You’re a novelist who spends a number of time on TikTok taking a look at critiques of your e book, you aren’t going to empower your self to be an open, free creator. You’ll give your self a number of inhibitions, complexes and dangerous emotions. I don’t spend time Googling myself. I used to be grateful to be having them, no query. However I can not and won’t do a deep dive.
A We Have been Liars present was first reported in 2023 at Prime Video. Was there an curiosity to adapt this story? Why was now the right time to have or not it’s tailored?
We Have been Liars has been in growth because it first got here out. So first for [a] function, I believe it had 5 writers and two totally different administrators connected, after which at one other streaming service for tv with a distinct showrunner. After which they got here again to me, and I used to be in a position to place it with [Julie] Plec and [Carina Adly] MacKenzie and the explanation I went with them, amongst a bunch of various presents, was that they stated they’d present run it, so I wasn’t optioning it simply to a producer or to a streaming service. As an alternative, there was a artistic group connected that had made a ton of tremendous bingeable, horny, enjoyable tv that I actually loved, and likewise each of these folks had learn the e book a number of occasions, had a number of very considerate issues to say about it.
You exec produced the collection and assisted with casting and placement scouting. Was it vital to you to have massive enter on the difference of this? What sort of conversations did you might have with what was vital to you when bringing this to life?
Properly I wrote the finale, and I felt nice that they trusted me with the finale and to convey the story residence. I had been a part of a growth room that occurred earlier than Plec wrote the pilot, and that was a 10-week dialog with the three of us, but additionally a bunch of different writers, and that was in regards to the core themes that we’d convey from the e book to the present, what crucial parts had been, what the emotional impact we wished to have. I believe one factor that makes this present totally different from the opposite Succession– fashion household dramas about rich folks behaving badly or from the opposite beachy thrillers (Sirens, Excellent Couple, and many others.) or from the opposite teen dramas, I’ve sufficient chutzpah to say that our story is extra emotional than all of these, and what we wish to do is absolutely join you to those characters and pack an emotional wallop on the finish. I really like all these exhibits I simply talked about, however that’s not their principal impact. And so as soon as these themes and central considerations had been clear they went off and had a author’s room that I used to be not in [because] I used to be residence writing a novel. However I got here to the author’s room and spent two weeks breaking the finale along with the group of author.
You wrote the final episode, which is clearly pivotal given it’s when the e book’s twist is revealed. Did you pitch to jot down the final episode and what was vital to you to jot down that one particularly? Was it your first time writing a screenplay?
They invited me to jot down it. I’ve written a pair pilots for various streamers that simply have by no means gotten made. So this was my first piece of tv writing to be filmed, however not my first piece of tv writing. I used to be somewhat daunted by the motion sequences, as a result of once I’m writing fiction and there are motion sequences, I’ve to work lengthy and arduous to get these to sort of pop off the web page. My pure house is dialogue, emotions, romance, banter. Motion is is at all times one thing I actually work on and out of the blue I used to be given probably the most motion of the complete season. However a room filled with writers serving to you construction an editorial is a extremely enjoyable reward. You don’t get that as a novelist, and also you don’t get it as a author of pilots, both. So I really like being within the writers room. I cherished listening to all the pieces that Plec and MacKenzie needed to say in regards to the construction that they wished the episode to have as a way to repay all of the issues that had come earlier than. That author’s room is an enchanting and enjoyable place to be.
Given the twist is so pivotal within the e book, a part of its energy comes from folks not realizing it. Given the e book has been on the market for a while, had been you involved in any respect about whether or not the present would possibly be capable of ship the identical punch as your e book? Are you able to speak about crafting the twist for the present versus whenever you crafted it within the e book?
You possibly can at all times search for spoilers on the web. That is doable for each single film, each single e book, each single tv present. I don’t assume folks wish to have their their expertise spoiled. They don’t need the tip to the thriller. They don’t need the answer to Cadence’s amnesia till they expertise it on this present. So we’ve got for the present an identical marketing campaign to the one which we had for the e book when it first got here out, which is simply inviting individuals who know the ending, individuals who’ve learn the e book or individuals who will binge watch the present on June 18, to lie; Inviting them to be within the know with us and to lie. I believe it’s enjoyable to be within the membership of people that know a narrative already. And one factor that I by no means thought would occur with We Have been Liars, as a result of it’s a story with an enormous plot twist, is I by no means thought I’d have readers who reread it again and again and over. Folks come to my signings with post-it notes and sticky notes all by means of their copies. They arrive with a tattoo on their arm. They arrive and inform me what number of occasions they’ve learn the e book. So I don’t assume we’re nervous. Persons are not there just for the plot twist. They’re there for the emotions and the characters on this planet.
I think about readers rereading it are trying again on particulars to place two and two collectively that results in the ending or the little particulars they possibly didn’t discover earlier than. What are the issues they’ve instructed you about their rereads?
One factor is that they simply wish to hang around with the liars once more. I believe that though that is an island the place some horrible issues occur, folks like returning to Beechwood. They like returning to the friendship and to the relationships between these characters. The opposite factor is that each the e book and the present are threaded fully by means of with hints and clues to the thriller that you simply see on a second watch otherwise you see on a second learn.
Given the story explores quite a lot of issues whether or not or not it’s wealth and privilege, friendship, household, and sophistication, what did you specific with the creatives on this present that you simply wished to get throughout thematically on this collection that you simply aimed to get throughout on this e book?
There’s a scene at that within the within the finale the place Cadence is speaking to Johnny, they usually’re each speaking about having enormous regrets and disgrace and horror at issues that they’ve achieved of their life. And I believe a number of my books and the present ask this query of, what do you do if you end up ashamed of your self? What do you do whenever you’ve achieved one thing horrible? Are you able to forgive your self? Are you able to make some sort of reparation? Are you able to go on on this planet and do good issues and nonetheless settle for the dangerous issues that you simply’ve achieved? An ethical reckoning that I believe is a part of the journey to maturity. I actually love that scene, and I really like the way in which Joseph Zada and Emily Alyn Lind acted. Johnny says to Cadence, “You’re going to go on and do good issues. That doesn’t change the previous, however you’re going to go on and dwell an entire life filled with magnificence and goodness. And that’s that’s an choice for you, and that’s at all times an choice for all of us.”
Given you had been on set throughout filming, what sort of conversations did the actors have with you, if any, about their characters?
They had been all extremely considerate and pleasant. That stated, if you happen to’re the novelist and you’re on set, even if you happen to wrote the episode that they’re filming, you don’t get in there and begin speaking to the actors about their characters. You let the director speak to the actors. You let the showrunner speak to the actors, however you do not need to be getting of their heads or contradicting one thing. So the chats I’ve had with the actors, I often attempt to keep out of that and simply present my appreciation and enthusiasm for what they’re doing, as a result of that they had all learn the books. They’d all an funding in portraying the characters vulnerably and precisely and in truth, they usually had been doing it. So I didn’t must spend my time like speaking to them about Johnny’s motivation, or no matter. I wanted to only say, “You’re bringing it!” I simply tried to point out them the love.
As within the e book, the present’s characters are predominantly white, which displays the Sinclair household’s privileged and remoted world. Nevertheless, the story explores privilege and the societal impression of white identification and social standing particularly with Gat and Ed. And Gat expresses that to Cadence in a number of moments all through the present and clearly resulting in their determination of burning the Beechwood residence. Are you able to speak about exploring that in your story and Gat’s place in relation to the opposite liars that you simply wished to get throughout?
Properly, every time I’m writing an vital character who has a really totally different identification or lived expertise than my very own, there’s at all times analysis to do, however there additionally must be some extent of entry the place I greatest hook up with that character myself. Gat is a center class New Yorker, mental child, sort of on hearth with concepts and the urge to critique and unpack and perceive the world round him. And it means he talks an excessive amount of typically, and it means typically his pals don’t wish to hear what he’s bought to say. And he’s navigating that, and he’s additionally bought one foot in and one foot out of this actually privileged world. These ways in which I simply described him, that was me. I used to be a scholarship child at some actually fancy instructional establishments. I used to be that child with my hand up on a regular basis. I used to be the child who talked greater than my pals wished to listen to me speak. I used to be at all times the one who did the studying and was yammering on in school. So I discovered these connection factors between me and Gat, and I believe that’s why as a white feminine writer, I used to be capable of finding connection factors with a teenage boy of Indian descent.
Once we had been writing the TV present, Plec and MacKenzie employed 4 writers of Indian descent to work on our present, so we had folks of various expertise ranges and ability ranges. We had a variety of expertise and backgrounds within the room. However when it comes to our writers of Indian descent, additionally they shared their lived expertise with the room and deepened and fleshed out, not solely the character of Gat but additionally his Uncle Ed, in order that there’s extra to their story than it might ever have been within the e book authored simply by me. It’s extra genuine, it’s extra nuanced, and it’s simply higher than we might have achieved with out all these totally different voices on the desk. I’m excited for folks to see that. I believe they’re gonna get to know these characters in a in a much bigger, extra genuine manner,
We study on the finish that Cadence is the only real Liar provided that the remainder of the Liars had been killed within the hearth at Beechwood and he or she has been hallucinating their existence ever since. She is left to not solely grapple with this tragedy and her involvement in that but additionally what’s subsequent: proceed on with the Sinclair legacy and uphold the lie of what actually occurred that evening to the general public or distance herself completely from the household. Are you able to speak about her journey and ending?
I believe in a number of methods, Cadence place will not be easy. We didn’t wish to dumb something down, however we wished to have a sense of launch. On the finish, I used to be speaking in regards to the island being remoted from the remainder of the world, the pressures that occur whenever you’re spending all summer time on one island with a patriarch who type of dictates what the foundations of that world are. What occurs on the shut of We Have been Liars is that Cadence kicks off her excessive heels and he or she runs down the seashore barefoot. That was a beautiful second. I don’t assume Emily Lynn was imagined to go barefoot, as a result of, truthfully, they don’t need our actresses operating naked ft down the shore. However the drones had been up, the footwear had been off! After which she will get within the boat and he or she drives away. She’s going away from the island, having set herself free from the rigidities, guidelines, the prejudices, the bullshit of the household. Everyone knows that this may be an ongoing journey to separate from your loved ones of origin. And it’s not a easy factor in any respect. And so, you realize, we will see.
In true suspenseful style, the story ended with suspense. Are you able to speak about that ending second with Johnny’s spirit talking along with his mother Carrie (Mamie Gummer)?
I wrote a prequel novel to We Have been Liars, which is known as Household of Liars. And that scene between Johnny and Carrie is similar to the opening scene of Household of Liars. It’s a tip of the hat to the story that I in-built that second e book.
There’s a prequel to We Have been Liars launched in 2022, Household of Liars, and it was additionally optioned. Are you aware if a prequel collection would possibly occur if We Have been Liars does effectively?
I don’t have any information to share about season two but. [But] it’s not a restricted collection!
Then you definately’re additionally releasing a 3rd e book within the We Have been Liar universe, which is releasing this fall. What can readers count on in We Fell Aside?
We Fell Aside is about on this planet of We Have been Liars, and it has a brand new forged of characters, however it additionally reveals a number of Sinclair household secrets and techniques. So it intersects with We Have been Liars all through, and it occurs the identical time interval as We Have been Liars in one other massive, beachy, Gothic Home throughout the water on Martha’s Winery.
***
We Have been Liars is streaming now on Prime Video.